Munchie: Gourd yourself

Pumpkin pie at Dangerously Delicious Pies

Ingredients: Handmade pumpkin pie

Damage: $20 for a whole (pictured), $5 for a slice

Skinny: Most of the pies at Dangerously Delicious are fabulous. This one was OK, bordering on a bit boring. On the pumpkin pie spectrum, it about tied with my mother's version on flavor, but didn't even come close to touching my grandmother's. Bottom Line: It was average in taste and price, but would make even Rachael Ray yawn, shrug her shoulders and say, "Eh. It's just pumpkin pie."—Jen Bunty