Home > Music > CD Review > The New Pornographers, "Challengers"

Backstory: A couple years back, frontman Carl “A.C.” Newman moved to Brooklyn from his native Vancouver and recorded most of this album at a Park Slope studio. Longtime collaborator Dan Bejar dropped by for chunks of time to hammer out tunes and eat really good thin crust pizza. Though alt-country bombshell Neko Case still sings on the album, Newman made an effort to include his niece (and touring Case fill-in) Kathryn Calder on the album—she sings lead on the tremolo-driven song “Failsafe.”

Why you should care: With the mature, genre-stretching “Challengers,” the New Pornographers is anything but the indie pop supergroup you spazz danced to a few years ago. “Unguided” is a gorgeously arranged epic, with strings, a Nashville-tuned acoustic guitar and flutes leaking in at the sixth minute (paging Jethro Tull). The Neko Case-lead “Go Places” is a tender love song, straightforward and knee-buckling. “Mutiny, I Promise You” is the best compromise between the band’s old and new sounds, with an organ hook (old school), off-kilter time signatures (new school), a slow, sweeping bridge (new school) and Case/Newman harmonies (both schools, thankfully).

Verdict: The band’s best album to date. Carl Newman flips the script record-to-record, which makes us pretty damn excited about his anticipated ’08 solo album. Plus, the electro-pop sugar cube album is pretty played out—just ask Hot Hot Heat.

X-Factor: The Canadian government subsidizes the band’s touring and recording expenses—and Newman doesn’t even live there. Looks like somebody has a fan in Ottawa.

You will be prompted to register or log in when posting.

Comment

Please note that by clicking on "Post Comment" you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator.