Poisons: Dogwood Deli

Tonya's wish at Dogwood Deli

Ingredients: Kahlua, dark rum and pineapple juice served on the rocks with an orange wedge and a cherry

Damage: $10

Skinny: A cocktail that's possibly what every girl has always wished for, Tonya's wish combines delicious tropical flavors with a subtle hint of chocolate. Don't be fooled by the unattractive, muddy color. This drink tastes like a perfect night on the beach, and delivers plenty of alcohol. Who wouldn't wish for that? Definitely something we'll go back for (and maybe try to make at home).—Michael Cook